Saturday, July 29, 2006

Primera publicación

Me han aceptado un mini-paper! Yo quería presentarlo como paper pero mi tutora dijo que mi nivel de inglés era insuficiente y que empezara con un poster (mini-paper de dos caras). Evidentemente en dos caras no puedes poner mucho y los revisores me han criticado eso:

What is the weakness of the paper? (1-3 sentences)
  • The idea is not developed sufficiently. The paper only describes the seed of the concept and leaves the rest to future work. The simulations are not thorough enough.
  • This short paper is basically an extended abstract. We would like to see more algorithmic analytical and experimental details. I realize that a 2 page paper can't capture these. What are the issues that will come up with respect to a physical implementation?
  • The paper is so brief. I wonder why you did not use the eight page limit allocated to all papers. This would have made the paper much stronger.
Pero las conclusiones son buenas:
  • The protocol is simple, clean and has nice properties
  • A novel or new contribution to this area with good methodology, or an incremental contribution paper that has excellent methodology. A must read for anyone in the area.
  • Interesting idea that could be developed into a usable protocol for underwater networks
Con un poco de suerte (aunque no lo creo porque supongo que ira mi tutora) en septiembre me voy a California a presentarlo. Ahora tengo que desarrollarlo para presentarlo en la próxima conferencia del IEEE.

1 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

gozas!!! si al final mi hermano va a ser util y to!! yo me ofrezco a taladrarle las rotulas al que se le ocurra chafarte la idea (que quieres chico, cada uno tenemos dones diferentes). bueno, ya contaras a ver q t dicen

7/29/2006 1:09 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home